热度 36|
九九: "这部《Life of PI》的电影主题我很感兴趣。一个男孩和一只孟加拉虎劫后余生,在一只小船上,在浩瀚的太平洋漂泊了227天后居然生还,不是奇迹那是什么?&qu ...
九九: 原来如此 但还是很想听大家讨论下
graceusa: 还没看。
对李安的看法和你完全相同。
Highway: 要说内容吗,我觉得剧情是本部电影的短板。当然了,有人说是编剧改编的不好,原著还是很流畅的。
按PI的说法,这一场际遇彻底改变了他对God的看法,我觉得很勉 ...
Highway: 李安还有一个不常为人知的秘密,那就是他感情特别女性化,特别爱哭。据说《色戒》拍到艰难处,他老哥经常一个人找个墙角,抱头大哭。。。 ...
九九: 我觉得,无论是原著还是书,用最后那么一丢丢的篇幅和口吻来讲这另一个故事,与其说是为了让PI自圆其说,还不如说是拿读者/观众“开涮”…… ...
Q. What a thought-provoking story! My question is which story was in your mind the actual one? Was it his faith in God which allowed him to experience the "animal"; version and to protect him from the gruesome reality? Was that the wonder of the story that you intended? I have difficulty even asking because I firmly believe that a story is determined somewhere in the intersection of reader and text. I am curious though, what your intended interpretation was. — Sarah
A. Dear Sarah, I leave it to the reader to choose which is the better story. It can go both ways. Pi survived with Richard Parker and then, confronted with the skepticism of the Japanese, and wanting his suffering to be validated, to be accepted, he creates another story, the story without animals. That's one reading. Or Pi and his mother and the French cook and a Taiwanese sailor survive, it turns into a butchery and Pi invents the story with animals presumably to pass the time and to make acceptable the unacceptable, that is, the murder of his mother by the Frenchman and Pi's killing of the Frenchman. Both stories are offered, one is on the outer edges of the barely believable, the other is nearly unbearable in its violence, neither explains the sinking of the ship, in both Pi suffers and loses his family, in both he is the only human survivor to reach the coast of Mexico. The investigators must choose and the reader must choose. When the investigators choose the story with animals, Pi answers "And so it goes with God"; In other words, Pi makes a parallel between the two stories and religion. His argument (and mine) is that a vision of life that has a transcendental element is better than one that is purely secular and materialist. A story with God ("God" defined in the broadest sense) is the better story, I argue, just as I think the story with animals is the better story. But you choose.
Highway: 怎么拿观众/读者开涮了,愿闻其详?我个人觉得那才是the best part。
下面摘一段文字,希望能help a little bit:
九九: Thanks a lot. That's exactly what I was joking about. The arrangement of the movie/novel is designed intentionally to leave the dilemma to the reader. ...
Highway: 谢谢你的的回复,先献一束花!
看来九九女侠也是好电影之人,日后一定多多求教。
不过呢, ...
丁丁咚: 不会吧,现在国人对印度的偏见已经到了连印度题材的电影都会有心理障碍的程度?
我以前在西西河,有一次就是因为很好奇(因为我对印度真的完全不了解,网上那种 ...
GMT+8, 2024-5-13 09:48 , Processed in 0.029787 second(s), 18 queries , Gzip On.
Powered by Discuz! X3.2
© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc.